The successful slow death of management consultants
We’re all familiar with the popular image of the management consultant: A sharp-suited, ideas machine who parachutes in, identifies “synergies”, encourages job cuts, and maybe gets your boss to take you on a raft-building, motivational exercise in the Welsh hills.
If that’s your experience, then the good news is that these external agencies could be on their way out. Don’t cheer for too long though, as this is only down to company bosses enthusiastically buying into some of the key concepts of the industry.
Our recent research into the changing nature of management details this internalisation of consulting. Management work is becoming less hierarchical (on the surface at least) and more market and change oriented – a sort of hybrid of both old-fashioned bureaucracy and its post-modern or chaotic opposite.
One way in which this change is happening is by adopting a model based on external management consultancy which we call “management as consultancy”. This is happening through three different routes.
Firstly, large organisations are recruiting former external consultants into management positions, especially favouring those from blue chip consulting firms. This has resulted in the growing diffusion of a particular approach to managing, using rigid change methods and project management tools which workers will recognise from their appearance on white boards in the form of lots of boxes with even more arrows connecting them.
Secondly, management groups within organisations, such as those in information technology (IT), accounting and human resources (HR) are reinventing themselves as consultants. This was already the case with external accounting and IT firms who boosted their income through consulting services. But now the aim is to enhance the occupational status of specific managerial groups within organisations by borrowing from the prestige of external consultants.
As one re-fashioned HR manager we interviewed claimed:
I’m not sitting behind a desk in an ivory tower, hidden… I’m very mobile, so if I need to be in another location, the car is under the building and I move, so I’m mobile and truly like a consultant.
Of course, this can sometimes go wrong. There is stigma as well as status attached to the management consultant identity.
The third way in which management is internalising consulting is the extension of what were once termed “internal consulting units”. These have long represented the less fashionable side of consulting, although large organisations often found them effective. They are now re-branding themselves with titles such as “programme management” and “performance delivery”. They may still have a precarious existence though, subject to the whims of new CEOs or waves of job-cuts. As one such consultant manager pointed out:
We don’t actually have proper jobs. If they abolished us tomorrow, what would change?
Despite such pessimism, these units can thrive for years. And even if they are cut, they often re-emerge in different parts of the organisation with a new name.
Taken together, the result of these changes is an emerging group of “consultant managers” in large public and private sector organisations. This has important implications for the future of management.
For example, if management groups such as human resources take on a consulting identity, they risk becoming dispensable. Also, while some managers may appear more professional in such a role, they can lose accountability, much like external consultants. Can all managers then, become like consultants in their approach?
Although consulting can come in different forms (some of it resembles counselling more than management), we found that the model adopted tended to be at the harder end of the spectrum. It was focused on short-term gains, on what businesses like to call “value add” and on using mechanistic tools such as those taught on many MBA programmes. In such a world, alternative approaches to organising – such as those stressing longer-term goals, employee participation and capability building – risk being marginalised.
The rise of the “consultant manager” also has implications for external management consultancy, which has become a global multi-billion dollar industry. At the top level, consultants are seen as “masters of the universe”, shaping business organisations and governments across the world. However, business commentators have highlighted a range of disruptive threats to this model, including the “small armies of former consultants” being hired by businesses directly. Our research echoes this point, but also highlights how management consulting is not so much a successful, elite profession, but a type of management.
If the trend towards management as consultancy continues, then external consultancy risks both substitution and de-mystification. It would be as if the success of management consultancy has paradoxically led to the demise of the external consultant – if not the death of those motivational weekends in the Welsh Hills.
No doubt the consulting industry will respond to this and other threats, as it has in the past. It could focus more on projecting its expertise as a rare commodity and on its “outsider” role of rubber-stamping decisions. Whatever the outcome, management consultants should no longer be seen simply as influential outsiders but as part of the management mainstream.
Andrew Sturdy is Head of Department of Management and Chair in Management at University of Bristol; Christopher Wright is Professor of Organisational Studies at University of Sydney, and Nick Wylie is Senior Lecturer at Oxford Brookes University