updated 5:50 PM CDT, Aug 11, 2019
What is the difference between purpose and meaning?
Why is the focus on the human element important now?
Amendment to EEA Regulations: New format for EEA4
Separation of disciplinary enquiries into two parts
Protection of Personal Information Policy
Influenza Vaccine Consent Form
The difference between a work practice and a term and condition of employment
Disconnected from global trends? The right of employees to digitally disconnect
Right to disconnect
Lots of young South Africans aren’t going to technical colleges. What can be done
A+ A A-

Department of Correctional Services v Van Vuuren 1999 (20) ILJ 2297 Labour Appeal Court Decision

Department of Correctional Services v Van Vuuren 1999 (20) ILJ 2297 Labour Appeal Court Decision

FACTS: The respondent, a well qualified white female employee of the Appellant department, applied for a post at the St Albans prison in Port Elizabeth. After interviewing 31 applicants the interview panel recommended only 4 applicants for the post. The respondent was strongly recommended and head of the list. The decision to make the appointment rested with the Commissioner of Correctional Services and he decided not to appoint the respondent but appointed a black male instead.

The respondent approached the Industrial Court on the basis that the failure to appoint her amounted to an unfair labour practice. The Court ruled in her favour finding that the pre-condition for the implementation of the Department’s affirmative action policy, namely registration, had not occurred by the time the Commissioner made his decision. The appellant sought to overturn that finding on appeal.

HELD: The Commissioner was competent to decide whom to appoint to the post. He was further competent to do so in terms of s8(3) of the Interim Constitution, 1993, the affirmative action clause "designed to achieve the adequate protection and advancement of persons or groups or categories of persons disadvantaged by unfair discrimination, in order to enable their full and equal enjoyment of all rights and freedoms". This appointment is also in line with s212(2)(b) which states that the public administration of South Africa must be broadly representative of the South African community. In terms of s210(1)(a)(3) of the Interim Constitution the Public Services Commission is competent to give directions for appointments and promotions in the public service and in terms of s210(1)(a)(3) these directions should generally be implemented within 6 months. The Commissioner thus acted within his powers when he made the decision. Whilst he did not adhere to a fixed policy or principle in making his decision he gave careful consideration to the circumstances of the respondent, the demands for representativity in that particular post in the Eastern Cape as well as other relevant factors.The application was dismissed and the appeal succeeded with costs.

COMMENT: The implementation of affirmative action measures are entrenched in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa. Registration of an Affirmative Action Policy is not a pre-requisite to implement affirmative action measures in the workplace.

Gary Watkins

Gary Watkins

Managing Director


C: +27 (0)82 416 7712

T: +27 (0)10 035 4185 (Office)

F: +27 (0)86 689 7862

Website: www.workinfo.com
Login to post comments

HR Associations